Pygmy Goat Mix vs Dry Goat Mix: Which Feed to Choose?
By Gladwells Pet & Country Stores Online Shop | Published: 2026-11-01
Category: Buying Guides
Compare Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix and Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix to decide which suits your goats, with practical feeding and buying advice.
Quick answer
For pygmy goats specifically, choose Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix 15kg because its higher fibre and dried fruit and vegetables match their natural foraging. For a balanced mix suitable for all goats and ages, choose Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix 20kg.
Why fibre matters for pygmy goats
Pygmy goats are browsers that naturally eat fibrous plants. A feed with higher fibre supports normal digestion and helps prevent problems linked to rich, low-fibre diets. Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix is formulated with higher fibre levels and includes dried fruit and vegetables, which mirrors the variety they would forage. This makes it a sensible default for pygmy goats, especially those on limited grazing or hay.
When a fully balanced all-goat mix is the better buy
If you keep a mixed herd or your goats are not pygmy, Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix offers a fully balanced option for goats of all types and ages. It removes the guesswork of matching feed to a specific breed and is practical when you want one feed for several animals. However, it does not provide the pygmy-specific fibre profile or the added dried fruit and vegetables of the Allen & Page mix.
Pack size, price and storage trade-offs
Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix comes in a 15kg bag, while Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix is 20kg. A larger bag can be better value per kilogram, but only if you can store it properly and use it within its shelf life. For a single pygmy goat, a 15kg bag may be easier to manage and keep fresh. Neither product lists a full ingredient breakdown or feeding rate on this page, so check the bag label or contact the manufacturer for exact feeding amounts and transition advice.
Decision rules for choosing your goat mix
- Pygmy goats only: Choose Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix 15kg as the primary feed, because its higher fibre and dried fruit and vegetables are designed for the pygmy goat's natural browsing style. Check the bag for the recommended feeding rate and adjust for hay and grazing.
- Mixed herd or non-pygmy goats: Choose Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix 20kg for a fully balanced feed that suits all types and ages, avoiding the need for multiple products. If you also keep pygmy goats, consider feeding the Allen & Page mix separately to meet their specific needs.
- Small herd or storage limits: If you have one or two pygmy goats and limited storage, the 15kg Allen & Page bag is easier to use before it spoils; the 20kg Fancy Feeds bag may be better value for larger herds with proper storage. Always store feed in a cool, dry place and use within the manufacturer's recommended period.
Product facts
- Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix 15kg: Higher fibre levels with added dried fruit and vegetables. Supports digestion and offers foraging-like variety, making it a strong fit for pygmy goats.
Allen & Page Pygmy Goat Mix 15kg - Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix 20kg: Fully balanced mix for goats of all types and ages. Simplifies feeding when you have a mixed herd or goats of different ages.
Fancy Feeds Dry Goat Mix 20kg
Who should buy which?
Best for
- Pygmy goat owners who want a fibre-rich feed with added dried fruit and vegetables
- Smallholdings with one or two pygmy goats where a 15kg bag is manageable
Not for
- Goat keepers who need one balanced feed for a mixed herd of breeds and ages
- Owners looking for the largest bag size and lowest cost per kilogram
